One year later, how has "A Capital Commitment" worked?
Last April, Mayor Gray and DCPS Chancellor Kaya Henderson announced "A Capital Commitment," a 5-year strategic plan "to provide every [DCPS] student with a safe, academically challenging and inspiring learning experience." One year later, how has DCPS progressed toward these goals?
In the plan and a video DCPS produced to launch the campaign, Handerson predicts that 2012-2017 will be "a time of dramatic progress for DCPS." Let's look back at each of the goals and what has changed in the first year of the plan.
Goal 1: Increase District-wide math and reading proficiency to 70 percent while doubling the number of students who score at advanced levels of proficiency.
In the 2010-2011 school year, only 43% of DCPS students were proficient in both reading and math as measured by the DC CAS, meaning that by 2016-17, DCPS expects to see a 27-point increase. That mean that by 2016-17, 3,814 students would be advanced in reading and that 4,764 students would be advanced in math.
The 2012 DC CAS results, released last July by Mayor Gray and other city officials, showed that 44.7% of students were rated "proficient" in both reading and math, a level that actually shows growth over the past five years. 46% of DCPS students were rated proficient in math, up 2.7 points from 2011, and 43.5% were proficient in reading, reversing a 2-year trend of declining scores with a 0.5-point increase.
The 2012 DC CAS was administered in the same month as A Capital Commitment was released, meaning that last year's results would serve better as a benchmark for the effort, rather than as an indicator of progress under A Capital Commitment. The upcoming 2013 DC CAS testing, with its results expected to be released over the summer, will provide greater insight into whether DCPS has been able to achieve any significant growth in test scores in the first year of its 5-year effort.
Goal 2: Improve the proficiency rates for our 40 lowest-performing schools by 40 percentage points.
DCPS offered two concrete strategies to meet this goal. First, they created the Proving What's Possible (PWP) grants to offer low-performing schools to improve instruction, extend learning time, and make targeted technology investments.
During the current school year, 59 schools received a total of $10 million, in amounts ranging from $10,000 to $490,000, to launch new initiatives that range from technology enhancements and extended school day programs to data systems for truancy. (A partial list of awards is available here.) According to DCPS' press release announcing the first Proving What's Possible awards, approximately 85% of the $10 million went to DCPS' 40 lowest-performing schools.
In the FY2013-14 budget guidelines, DCPS says that it will continue the Proving What's Possible Grants, though only at $6.5 million. The budget guidelines say that 9 schools will receive funds to implement extended day programs, including at least 3 programs (Dunbar HS, Kelly-Miller MS and Noyes EC) that received PWP Funds for extended day programs in the current year.
FY2014 budget guidelines also show that 11 of the 40 lowest performing schools will receive PWP funds for additional literacy-focused personnel, including a school literacy assistant principal to improve teacher practice and a reading specialist to work directly with struggling readers.
Second, DCPS indicated that they would improve performance in their lowest-performing schools by investing "in the teachers, principals, and staff who interact with students every day" and by placing highly effective educators in those schools. DCPS has launched a new recruitment effort, but information on the percentage of highly rated principals and teachers in the 40 targeted schools as well as their retention rates are not currently publicly available.
Goal 3: Increase our high school graduation rate from 52 percent to 75 percent.
DCPS should be commended for its fidelity in implementing the national common core standards for high school graduation. The ensures that graduates with a diploma from a District high school are prepared for success in the workforce or in their continuing studies.
In addition to their focus on improving the proficiency of students, which will in itself impact graduation rates, DCPS has also committed in its FY2013-14 budget to expand non-traditional solutions to the graduation crisis facing the city.
DCPS has increased funding to schools to support credit recovery programs in its FY14 budget. Through these programs, District students can recover academic credits during the school day, over the summer and after school. In FY14, 15 District schools will receive funding in their school budgets for Evening Credit Recovery. Yet, until we see the effectiveness of these programs, DCPS's progress is difficult to assess.
Goal 4: Ensure that 90 percent of DCPS students like the school they attend.
DCPS officials offered several indicators for this measure: the level of dedicated staff who make meaningful connections with students; a rich and varied educational experience that includes art, music, and physical education; offering safe and modern facilities, quality meals, and current technology; and welcoming families and encouraging them to participate in their children's education. There was no baseline comparison for this goal and there is currently no information available to measure DCPS' progress towards the 90% goal.
Goal 5: Increase overall DCPS enrollment.
On this front, DCPS faces considerable challenges. Even as the number of school-age children across the city increases, DCPS saw a slight decline in enrollment this year. DCPS will also continue to face a growing challenge from the public charter school system, which now educates nearly ½ of all District public school students. Recent decisions to approve new public charter schools will add to challenges facing DCPS.
DCPS also faces a considerable challenge in keeping its own students. A year after the 2008 round of closures, a joint study by the 21st Century Schools Fund, Brookings and the Urban Institute came to the conclusion that thousands of students had left the DCPS system as a direct result of the closures. Despite a pledge to retail 80 percent of students displaced by DCPS' recent decision to close 15 schools over the next two years, there is little evidence that they will be able to reverse the flow to the public charter system.
After one year, A Capital Commitment continues to hold promise. However, DCPS can still be more transparent in how its budgetary and programmatic priorities align with the goals. Residents and policymakers need to see the data year after year to ensure that we're moving forward.
- School quality is the issue, says Catania. But his platform may not improve it.
- Wondering why a preschooler would ever need to be suspended? Here's an explanation.
- No more teaching to the test: Some DC teachers adopt a technique that gets students to think deeply
- MCPS superintendent responds to my Post op-ed